Jump to content

Bigger engine but less horsepower, how?


muzorty
 Share

Recommended Posts

Just now, Stu
6 minutes ago, geofferz said:

Anyway personally I don't bother looking at the torque figure - it's bollocks. I rode a Harley with loads of torque but super low revs so tiny bhp. It was horrifically slow - I couldn't appreciate any of its torquey goodness, it was slow in every gear at every rpm. 

 

Bhp matters. 

Torque is not bollocks! You ride on torque you race on bhp 

A Harley is not a good comparison to be honest but then it depends on the Harley too 

Get the right bikes to compare and you can tell the difference 

The TL I had would stomp out of corners leaving all sorts of bikes but get in to the higher revs you would get reigned in 

You can't ride on torque! Because you need revs. Which means bhp. Name 2 comparative bikes where the torquey one would beat the higher bhp one anywhere on the street or track?!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Mississippi Bullfrog
4 minutes ago, geofferz said:

Anyway personally I don't bother looking at the torque figure - it's bollocks. I rode a Harley with loads of torque but super low revs so tiny bhp. It was horrifically slow - I couldn't appreciate any of its torquey goodness, it was slow in every gear at every rpm. 

 

Bhp matters. 

You haven't ridden the Triumph 1200 twin. Loads of low end grunt but a relatively small bhp figure. But for passing lines of traffic on A roads the grin factor is huge. The downside is that accidentally twitch the throttle on a greasy roundabout and it gets very very interesting very very quickly. The power range is at a very usable 3000+ which makes instant acceleration in traffic a rather wonderful thing. The unwary BMW/Audi driver hears it coming, assumes it something like a Harley, thinks they won't get passed. They are wrong.

I have actually, I thought it was slow but I'm used to riding superbikes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, geofferz said:

You can't ride on torque! Because you need revs. Which means bhp. Name 2 comparative bikes where the torquey one would beat the higher bhp one anywhere on the street or track?!

You are missing the point! without one you don't have the other you ride on torque as that's the band of power you use all day long you race on bhp as you are constantly high in the revs 

I never said a torquey bike would beat a higher bhp bike on the street or track there is way too many variables to take in to consideration! 

Tight twisty roads are best on a bike with low down torque as you can pull harder from the apex than you can with a bike with lower torque but higher bhp the higher bhp will eventually take over but by then you are slowing down for the corner the Torquey motor would get you to a higher speed quicker than the lower torque bike! 

 

A mate of mine used to have a gsxr 750 SRAD 128bhp at the crank 59 ft-lb or torque 

At the same time I have the TL1000s 125 bhp at the crank 76 ft-lb of torque 

Both same year bikes too 

I would always pull away from him but it was never enough to leave him in a trail of dust it was just enough to get away a good 20 - 30 metres he could never real me in nor could I never leave him similar bhp yet different torque 

by the way getting on a V twin and riding it like a sports bike will never work you have to take time to learn where the power curves are and shift earlier you don't ride them in the higher revs like a sports bike you keep them lower 

It took me ages to learn the TL I was constantly hitting the rev limiter and felt like it was never moving till you look down and you're doing 140 :lol: 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, geofferz said:

You can't ride on torque! Because you need revs. Which means bhp. Name 2 comparative bikes where the torquey one would beat the higher bhp one anywhere on the street or track?!

Without torque you will go nowhere, period.

torque gets you there, BHP keeps you going.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, JRH said:

Without torque you will go nowhere, period.

torque gets you there, BHP keeps you going.

So putting this back to horses both bellow are 1 Hp:

Race horse:  High Speed - Low weight pulling capacity - Low stamina - relatively light weight.
Could be thought of as Low Torque high speed and acceleration.

Cart Horse:  Low Speed - High weight pulling capacity - High Stamina - relatively heavy weight.
Could be thought of as High Torque Low Speed and acceleration.

I am sure there are more types of horse out there as there are bikes...  Comparing a Harley and sports bike is like comparing the above.

horses for courses?

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, onesea said:

So putting this back to horses both bellow are 1 Hp:

Race horse:  High Speed - Low weight pulling capacity - Low stamina - relatively light weight.
Could be thought of as Low Torque high speed and acceleration.

Cart Horse:  Low Speed - High weight pulling capacity - High Stamina - relatively heavy weight.
Could be thought of as High Torque Low Speed and acceleration.

I am sure there are more types of horse out there as there are bikes...  Comparing a Harley and sports bike is like comparing the above.

horses for courses?

Don't forget the most important horse of all, the draught horse, shire horses have held records for being the biggest, which is very important where beer delivery is concerned 😁 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not bothered anymore . I have to say that really because I've just lost 100 hp and gained 100 cc . Still got the same castle though . ( And colour scheme , and bag ....)😉

Polish_20200804_091826936.png

Polish_20200803_190152230.jpg

Edited by fastbob
  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

And as a footnote , when this thing's on the road I'll be dropping a whopping 700 cc's but only 10 hp . It's a funny old world isn't it . 

Polish_20201122_003424325.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Bender said:

Haha ok I concede 👍 

 

 

AlthoughSpanish, Italian, German and Danish studs were used and later studs from the orient.

And Lipizzaner is the Italian name

I'm jus waffling to cover my tracks 😁 

 

I don't know what dobbin is in Slovenian, mind you I don't know what it is in Italian either 😂 

Not that I know something more, I am just born near there in Croatia, 40 min from Lipica and remember going horse riding with my parents .:thumb:

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

what I come with after turning off my polite keyboard 
 
dick (taboo, slang) 
prick (taboo, slang) 
member 
tool (taboo, slang) 
organ 
cock (taboo, slang) 
wang (US, slang)
knob (British, taboo, slang) 
chopper (British, slang) 
plonker (slang) 
dong (slang) 
winkle (British, slang) 
joystick (slang) 
pecker (US, Canadian, taboo, slang)
John Thomas (taboo, slang)
weenie (US, slang)
whang (US, slang)
tadger (British, slang)
schlong (US, slang)
pizzle (archaic, dialect) 
willie or willy (British, informal)
tockley (Australian, slang) 
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Marino said:
what I come with after turning off my polite keyboard 
 
dick (taboo, slang) 
prick (taboo, slang) 
member 
tool (taboo, slang) 
organ 
cock (taboo, slang) 
wang (US, slang)
knob (British, taboo, slang) 
chopper (British, slang) 
plonker (slang) 
dong (slang) 
winkle (British, slang) 
joystick (slang) 
pecker (US, Canadian, taboo, slang)
John Thomas (taboo, slang)
weenie (US, slang)
whang (US, slang)
tadger (British, slang)
schlong (US, slang)
pizzle (archaic, dialect) 
willie or willy (British, informal)
tockley (Australian, slang) 

Intentional Pun or not 

Edited by TimR
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Marino said:

For years I believed that Croatian language is champion in swearing and bad, rude words. But checking on English, I am amazed how many synonyms just for small piece of extra skin:classic_love: 

Greek is pretty impressive as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Welcome to The Motorbike Forum.

    Sign in or register an account to join in.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Guidelines We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Please Sign In or Sign Up